John Hinderaker at PowerLine shares some common sense objections to California's mad dash to electric vehicles (and yes, it's coming to Ohio also):
Are people finally starting to
catch on to the fact that electric vehicles are a terrible idea? I hope so.
Bjorn Lomborg makes the case in accessible form in the Wall
Street Journal. To begin with, EVs don’t even save much on CO2 emissions:
Over its lifetime, an electric car does emit less CO2 than a gasoline
car, but the difference can range considerably depending on how the electricity
is generated. Making batteries for electric cars also requires a massive amount
of energy, mostly from burning coal in China. Add it all up and the
International Energy Agency estimates that an electric car emits a little less
than half as much CO2 as a gasoline-powered one.
What does that up to, in terms of
climate?
If every country achieved its stated ambitious electric-vehicle targets
by 2030, the world would save 231 million tons of CO2 emissions. Plugging these
savings into the standard United Nations Climate Panel model, that comes to a
reduction of 0.0002 degree Fahrenheit by the end of the century.
On that basis alone, the left’s
mania to make us all drive electric vehicles is insane. But from there on, the
story is all negative:
Electric cars’ impact on air pollution isn’t as straightforward as you
might think. The vehicles themselves pollute only slightly less than a gasoline
car because their massive batteries and consequent weight leads to more
particulate pollution from greater wear on brakes, tires and roads. On top of
that, the additional electricity they require can throw up large amounts of air
pollution depending on how it’s generated. One recent study found that electric
cars put out more of the most dangerous particulate air pollution than
gasoline-powered cars in 70% of U.S. states. An American Economic Association
study found that rather than lowering air pollution, on average each additional
electric car in the U.S. causes additional air-pollution damage worth $1,100
over its lifetime.
. . .
Left-wing governments are on a
collision course with normal Americans. Governments want to force Americans to
rely on wind and solar energy, but those sources can’t keep the lights on and
are ruinously expensive. Similarly, governments want to force us all into
electric vehicles, which are not as functional as gas-powered vehicles, despite
being more expensive. And they are a net detriment to the environment. Lomborg
is optimistic, perhaps more so than I am:
Read the rest here.
And Mr. Hinderaker didn’t even get to the problems with existing minerals
required to produce the batteries, or the disposal of spent batteries, or the
horrific damage done by strip mining to extract, say, the lithium (see aerial
image at the top).
# # #
