art credit: inforrm.wordpress.com
Without consulting with its users,
Microsoft has installed an establishment media browser extension, purportedly
designed to rate the accuracy of news websites, as a default setting on mobile
versions of its Edge browser. In practice, it creates a news blacklist by
warning users away from sites including Breitbart News, The Drudge Report, and
the Daily Mail.
The browser extension, called
“Newsguard,” presents users with a red warning label if they navigate to a
website that it judges to be unreliable. A “green” rating is given to websites
that NewsGuard considers trustworthy.
A number of pro-Trump websites,
including Breitbart News, are given a “red” rating by the extension.
In a March 2018 interview with
NewsGuard Executive Editor James Warren, establishment conservative Bill
Kristol correctly noted that NewsGuard, an app and browser plug-in which allows
users to avoid what it considers “fake news” websites, would face skepticism
since “establishment people” like “establishment websites.” NewsGuard has added
Breitbart News, the Drudge Report, and the Daily Mail to its “fake
news” blacklist.
. . .
NewsGuard lists Breitbart News,
the Daily Mail, and the Drudge Report as fake news websites, but gives the
all-clear to CNN, Buzzfeed, the Guardian, the New York
Times, the Washington Post, and Vice News, despite recent high profile
fake news stories from a variety of these approved sites.
CNN? Buzzfeed? New York Times? Good grief. Who is making the
decisions about what is and is not Fake News. Yet more media and social malpractice.
UPDATE 8:35pm on 1/23: A reader posted this as Reply #3 at the Lucianne aggregator:
While I think this is terrible, it
is only on the phone version of [Mircrosoft's] Edge. Since the three users of that browser
work for Microsoft I am not sure that anyone will notice.
# # #